VirginIslandsEverything 🔥 Viral
COURT

Woman sues Oriental Bank over $60,000 diverted from father's estate

A North Carolina resident alleges a former bank employee and accomplice stole her inheritance through unauthorized checks and Las Vegas spending.

A stack of financial documents and bank statements on a desk beside a gavel, with the US Virgin Islands flag in the background, cinematic lighting, no faces or identifiable people
Illustration (AI-generated)

Edna Smith-Gilchrist has filed a lawsuit against Oriental Bank, claiming that a former customer service representative orchestrated the theft of $60,000 meant for her as beneficiary of her late father's accounts.

According to the complaint filed November 12 in Superior Court, Jahmaira Farrell arranged for a manager's check to be issued to Mylon Allen on March 1, 2022, without Smith-Gilchrist's knowledge or consent. Allen deposited the check into his Banco Popular account the next day, then obtained a $60,000 official check made out to Farrell on March 10. Farrell deposited those funds into a Bank of St. Croix account she had opened a week earlier and spent the money on airline tickets, a Las Vegas hotel stay at The Palazzo at the Venetian Resort, jewelry and furniture, the lawsuit states.

Smith-Gilchrist, who lives in North Carolina, had authorized her sister Rufina Smith to handle closing her father Henry Smith's accounts locally. The accounts held a certificate of deposit worth $55,555.21 and a savings account containing $128,658.36, with Smith-Gilchrist named as beneficiary. Oriental Bank paid her $124,173.57, which she accepted as the full amount. She says she never signed any closing or disbursement documents and received no paperwork explaining how the proceeds were distributed.

The complaint alleges the bank violated its own safeguards. According to Oriental's Monetary Transactions Manual, manager's checks over $10,000 required two authorized signatures, including from a manager or operations leader. The lawsuit contends both the original and replacement checks were approved without verifying the recipient's entitlement or obtaining Smith-Gilchrist's authorization.

The case is linked to a separate $100,000 theft from customer Lennox Cato's accounts, also involving Farrell and Allen. An Oriental investigation in August 2022 found that Farrell had created unauthorized paperwork, forged Cato's signature and obtained payment without his presence, leading to her termination. Smith-Gilchrist's lawsuit argues the bank should have reviewed Farrell's earlier transactions at that time, which would have revealed the diversion from her father's estate.

Cato and his representative reported their loss to Oriental in July 2024. Police began investigating in January 2025 and obtained documents for the Smith transaction through a subpoena. Farrell was arrested on June 9, 2025, and Allen surrendered the following day in connection with the Cato allegations.

Smith-Gilchrist did not learn of the $60,000 loss until October 14, 2026, during a telephone call about her potential involvement as a witness in the Cato case. An Oriental Corporate Security investigator later acknowledged reviewing records of the Smith transaction and recognizing Farrell's involvement but stated the bank had not opened an investigation because Smith-Gilchrist had not filed a claim. She says she had no way to file a claim without knowing the theft had occurred.

Represented by attorney C. Jacob Gower, Smith-Gilchrist is seeking recovery of the $60,000, additional recoverable losses, three times actual damages under a stolen-property claim, punitive damages, interest, costs and attorney's fees. She also demands an additional $40 she alleges was withheld without authorization and has requested a jury trial.

How does this story make you feel?

Sources The Virgin Islands Consortium

📣 Know more about this story? Send us a tip. Photos welcome. Your identity stays private.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Create a comment

Comments are checked before they appear.