A heated exchange erupted in the House of Assembly on Tuesday when Opposition Leader Marlon Penn sought specifics about how the BVI Health Services Authority selected its new Chief Executive Officer, only to have Health Minister Vincent Wheatley refuse to answer.
Penn asked for the nationalities and rankings of finalists considered by the HSA board, whether the board's top choice was ultimately hired, and whether any qualified Virgin Islander was passed over. Wheatley would not provide those details, citing the confidential nature of recruitment proceedings.
The minister did disclose that the board had reconsidered its initial recommendation and submitted a different candidate for his approval. He also confirmed that Virgin Islanders had applied but none had reached the stage of being formally recommended for the position.
Penn objected to the secrecy, contending that a public institution's hiring should operate with transparency. "The minister cannot decide what he will or will not answer," Penn said, noting that his questions fell within the House's procedural rules and warranted responses. Wheatley held firm that recruitment matters must remain private, though he suggested future talks with the board might be possible.
Speaker Karl Dawson backed the minister, explaining that revealing applicant identities could harm those still employed elsewhere. Penn complied with the ruling but made clear his disagreement with it.
The dispute reflects mounting frustration over the appointment of Gordon Frame, a Scottish national who took up the CEO post on September 1, 2026. Frame previously held the position of National Director of Scheduled Care with NHS Scotland. The controversy intensified after Dr. June Samuels, who had acted as CEO for roughly two years, was not selected for the permanent role. Her exclusion has revived broader concerns that Virgin Islanders with substantial experience are regularly sidelined when senior positions open up.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.