A financing company is moving forward with a $6 million judgment against Juan Luis Hospital, rejecting the hospital's efforts to have the ruling set aside and signalling it will pursue collection even as legal questions about enforcement remain unresolved.
Varilease Finance sold operating equipment to the V.I. Government Hospitals and Health Facilities Corporation in exchange for approximately $6 million in cash, then leased the same equipment back to allow the hospital to continue patient care while making monthly payments. The arrangement gave Varilease ownership of the equipment and a lien on all hospital assets, including accounts receivable and property.
When the hospital stopped paying in November 2025 and did not respond to repeated outreach, Varilease filed suit in Michigan in March 2026. A Michigan court entered a default judgment in May, which Varilease registered in the District Court of the Virgin Islands in October.
In a court filing Friday, Varilease's attorney Lisa Michelle Komives said the company made multiple attempts over several months to resolve the matter directly with hospital leadership. "Plaintiffs' attempts were met with silence from VIGHHFC," she wrote. A demand letter sent in February also went unanswered, she said.
Komives stressed that Varilease does not seek to seize the operating equipment but intends to pursue the judgment fully. "Plaintiffs can and will refile suit, if necessary, and obtain an even larger Judgment," she wrote, noting that interest continues to accumulate.
Chief District Judge Robert Molloy has ordered Varilease to respond to the hospital's motion to set aside the Michigan judgment by Monday, Nov. 23. A hearing is scheduled for Monday, Dec. 28 on St. Croix.
The hospital has challenged whether a Michigan court has authority to order enforcement against V.I. assets, and whether hospital assets are protected from seizure under territorial law. Molloy raised these questions in an October order, noting that V.I. Code protects hospital corporation assets from judicial process including execution.
Komives countered that because the hospital specifically pledged all its assets as security for the lease, those assets are not exempt from execution. She also argued that the judgment properly ordered return of the equipment within 30 days, which the hospital has not done.
Meanwhile, the Legislature's Committee on Health, Hospitals, and Human Services will hold a hearing Tuesday, Nov. 24 to hear from hospital CEO Darlene Baptiste and executive leadership on the lease arrangements, their costs and approvals. The committee will also address the reported storage of human remains and body parts in trailers, oversight and corrective actions, as well as updates on the Charlotte Kimelman Cancer Institute opening, the St. Croix Kidney Dialysis Center completion, and other facility projects.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.