VirginIslandsEverything ๐Ÿ”ฅ Viral
COURT

Thirteen years on: Autopsy and inquest reach opposite conclusions in Micoud custody death

A 2015 coroner's jury ruled the 21-year-old's 2013 death an unlawful killing, but a recent autopsy review concluded it was self-inflicted.

The disputed last hours of Chacadan Daniel in a police cell
Photo: St. Lucia Times

Thirteen years after Chacadan Daniel was found dead in the Micoud Police Station, the manner of his death remains sharply contested. An autopsy peer review and a coroner's inquest have reached starkly different conclusions about how the 21-year-old came to die in custody on October 23, 2013.

Daniel's body was discovered with a white cloth tied around his neck and fastened to the burglar bars of his cell. An initial autopsy determined he died from asphyxia, a lack of oxygen caused by hanging. In a recent review, Dr Alfredo E Walker concluded the death was self-inflicted.

Yet a coroner's inquest convened in July 2015 reached the opposite finding. After hearing from 26 witnesses, many providing conflicting accounts, the jury determined that Chacadan died as a result of an unlawful killing: death at the hands of another without lawful justification.

Weeks of escalating tension

Chacadan's mother, Frances Daniel, said her son grew fearful of police in the weeks before his death. Court records indicate the sequence of events began in early to mid-October 2013.

On October 6, a female officer on duty reported that Chacadan, the only prisoner at the time, asked to use the bathroom and retrieve belongings from a locker. When released from his cell, he told the officer some items were missing and requested his freedom. A struggle ensued in which the officer was struck in the stomach and face. Chacadan then fled the station while another officer discharged his weapon, according to the female officer's account.

Two days after the escape, the officer who had fired shots visited Frances and told her Chacadan had fled custody, adding the warning: "funeral they making for him". In later testimony, this officer denied making that statement and initially claimed he was not working at Micoud in October 2013. When confronted with the female officer's account, he acknowledged he had in fact been at the station that month.

Police located Chacadan and returned him to the Micoud Police Station by October 21. Two days later, he was dead.

Sharply divergent accounts of his final hours

The station's log book recorded that Chacadan's body was found around 7:40 a.m. on October 23, shortly after Frances arrived at the station around 7:35 a.m. requesting to see her son. Yet witness statements from that morning tell conflicting stories.

One officer working as station orderly said he saw Chacadan alive just ten minutes before discovery. At 7:30 a.m., Chacadan called to him by nickname and asked for bathroom access. The orderly accompanied him, stood watch, and escorted him back to his cell, informing him he would be going to court that day.

A second officer's recollection differed markedly. He stated that roughly 20 minutes before Frances arrived, around 7:15 a.m., the station orderly had told him Chacadan had just bathed in preparation for his court appearance.

A cleaner who arrived around that time offered yet another version. She reported seeing the second officer, the station orderly and a third officer in the charge room area, and observed the second officer between the kitchen and charge room holding wet slippers at approximately 7:15 a.m.

Conflicting versions of discovery

The second officer stated he went alone to retrieve Chacadan when Frances requested to see him, leaving the station orderly at the front desk. Upon finding Chacadan's body suspended in the cell, he alerted other officers.

Frances gave a different account. She said the station orderly did not remain at the desk when she made her request. The second officer was later recorded as supporting her version, confirming that both he and the orderly went to fetch Chacadan.

The station orderly testified that when he checked the cell, he found Chacadan hanging by the neck from a noose fashioned from the white top Chacadan had been wearing. He entered the cell with the second officer, found no pulse, and they summoned a corporal before cutting down the noose.

Frances recalled considerable activity surrounding the cell immediately after the discovery. She observed police personnel wearing gloves moving items and noted that mopping occurred while Chacadan's body remained in the cell.

What lies ahead

Police Commissioner Verne Garde has stated his intention to pursue the case to resolution. The Daniel family continues seeking accountability and clarity about what transpired during their son's detention.

How does this story make you feel?

Sources St. Lucia Times

๐Ÿ“ฃ Know more about this story? Send us a tip. Photos welcome. Your identity stays private.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Create a comment

Comments are checked before they appear.