VirginIslandsEverything ๐Ÿ”ฅ Viral
COURT

St. John man charged after knife fight leaves woman with eye injury

A dispute over stove settings escalated into violence, leaving one woman with a corneal abrasion and the man facing domestic violence charges.

A dark-handled kitchen knife and metal bar on a tiled floor inside a home, with the US Virgin Islands flag visible in the background, dramatic lighting suggesting tension and conflict
Illustration (AI-generated)

A man from St. John has been arrested and charged with domestic violence following a physical confrontation that began with a disagreement over kitchen appliance settings.

Jose Starling Pena, who lives in the Pastory area, faces two misdemeanor counts: assault or battery with circumstances of aggravation and disturbance of the peace by threats, according to Superior Court records.

The conflict originated on Tuesday when Asly Olivo turned the apartment's gas stove to high repeatedly, creating safety concerns because minor children were in the home. Both Pena and Olivo's sister Jordiana Tolentino Olivo told police this prompted the dispute.

When Pena arrived home Wednesday afternoon around 1:45 p.m., Asly Olivo was waiting outside the staircase with a kitchen knife and attempted to attack him, according to statements from both Pena and Jordiana Olivo. Pena said he removed the knife from her hands before striking her in the left eye. He reported receiving scratches to his neck, chest, and left arm.

Asly Olivo gave police a different account, saying Pena punched her multiple times in the left eye, pulled her by the hair, forced her head into a wall, and approached her holding a knife.

A video recording showed a dark-handled kitchen knife falling to the tiled floor as Pena entered the home, though police noted the footage did not conclusively establish who held the knife first. A witness present in the home, identified as Ms. Ruiz, told investigators that after the initial clash, Asly Olivo threw a metal bar or refrigerator handle toward Pena inside his room. Pena then grabbed, pushed, and struck her in a second altercation that Ruiz and Jordiana Olivo separated.

Asly Olivo went to the Jurgen Command police station on St. John to report the assault. Officers observed swelling, redness, and purplish discoloration around her left eye. Medical evaluation revealed a left corneal abrasion. Pena received treatment at Schneider Regional Medical Center for superficial abrasions.

Pena was booked at the Richard N. Callwood Command on St. Thomas and held at the Bureau of Corrections. He appeared before Magistrate Judge Julie Smith Todman on Thursday morning, November 19.

How does this story make you feel?

Sources Virgin Islands Free Press

๐Ÿ“ฃ Know more about this story? Send us a tip. Photos welcome. Your identity stays private.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Create a comment

Comments are checked before they appear.