ST. CROIX: A proposed $15 million, 68-room hotel at Estate Mt. Welcome faces an ownership battle in Superior Court that has left the project in limbo.
Developer Stonehouse Junction LLC claims it bought the 0.83-acre parcel in January 2026 for $250,000, with a deed dated January 7 and recorded January 14. Businessman Allenton Browne and his company, Phoenix STX LLC, counter that they received the same property from co-trustees Nestor and Carmen Paraliticci on August 30, 2019, though they never recorded that deed.
On January 27, Browne ordered Stonehouse's contractors off the land. Police arrived, reviewed documents Browne presented and instructed the contractors to leave for the day, treating the matter as a civil dispute rather than a criminal one, court filings show.
Judge Ernest E. Morris Jr. stepped in with a temporary order signed September 23 and entered September 24. The ruling blocks Browne and Phoenix from accessing the parcel or stopping Stonehouse's work through December 7. The order does not settle who owns the land; it simply protects Stonehouse's ability to use it while the case continues.
Stonehouse argues it bought without knowledge of any competing claim, citing a seller's title affidavit and a title-insurance commitment that named the trustee as owner. Browne and Phoenix reject this, saying Stonehouse was aware of their earlier interest and should not be treated as an innocent buyer.
The hotel proposal gained traction in November when the Legislature approved rezoning the parcel on November 12 and sent the measure to the governor on November 13. Stonehouse principal Wally Hamed told lawmakers the facility would operate as an extended-stay hotel near the D.C. Canegata Ballpark, with financing secured and construction expected to take 18 to 24 months after final approvals.
On November 21, Browne, Phoenix and Nescar LLC sought default judgments against the Paraliticci parties and Arizona Inc., claiming those defendants were served in August and September but never responded.
A combined hearing on the injunction and a full trial are set for December 7 at 9 a.m. Court records do not indicate whether the ownership dispute has affected the project's financing or halted construction plans.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.