A federal magistrate judge has recommended throwing out parts of former Public Works Commissioner Gustav James's civil-rights lawsuit while giving him a second chance to fix the remaining claims.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Emile A. Henderson III issued the recommendation on November 16. He proposed eliminating the case against the Virgin Islands Police Department entirely, ruling that the territorial agency cannot be sued as a "person" under federal civil-rights law. The judge found that Governor Albert Bryan Jr. and Attorney General Gordon C. Rhea were named in the lawsuit but with no specific allegations about their conduct, and recommended those claims be dismissed without prejudice, allowing Mr. James to refile with more detail.
Mr. James, who is representing himself, has 30 days to revise his complaint to address the judge's concerns. The recommendation is not final; a district judge must review it, and both sides have 14 days from receiving it to lodge written objections.
Mr. James held the Public Works post under Governor Kenneth Mapp and stepped down in August 2017. His lawsuit, filed in May 2025, centres on a July 2021 incident in which he says DEA agents and VIPD officers entered his property without permission, restrained him, made him stand exposed to the sun and applied force that hurt his wrist and shoulder. He is seeking both compensatory and punitive damages.
A separate recommendation from November 4 dealt with Mr. James's federal tort claims. Judge Henderson recommended dismissing those as well without prejudice, finding that the complaint lacked proof he had gone through the required administrative claims process first. The judge noted, however, that Mr. James had filed a claim with the DEA, which rejected it on November 19, 2024, and that he had filed his lawsuit within the proper timeframe. He gave Mr. James another 30 days to amend that complaint to include those details.
The magistrate's recommendations address only legal and procedural matters and do not determine whether the alleged misconduct actually occurred.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.