Investigators examining the deadly collision between Ocean Angel and Cazorla Jr at Anse Cochon have pinpointed excessive speed as a critical factor, with both police and port authority officials offering their assessments at a public inquiry.
Acting Sergeant Mario Chicot from the Police Marine Unit told commissioners on November 9 that the damage patterns visible on both boats suggested they had been moving at "considerable speed" at impact.
Ship surveyor Peter Joseph, employed by the Saint Lucia Air and Sea Ports Authority, inspected the wreckage and appeared before the Commission on November 18. He characterised the collision as having "high impact" and told commissioners that "speed was involved there". When questioned further, Joseph was unambiguous: "There was speeding," he said, concluding both vessels had been travelling at high speed.
Since the inquiry opened public hearings in October, the speed of the two boats in their final moments has been a recurring focus. Witnesses have offered conflicting recollections.
Passenger Romean Williams, who was on Cazorla Jr, recalled the boat moving at a "really good speed" at one stage. The vessel's owner, Irenus Pascal, characterised the pace differently as "a little more than moderate" and said he had asked captain Tyson Hippolyte to "take it easy". Pascal stated that Hippolyte complied and slowed down.
On Ocean Angel, the situation differed between the two operators. Tyrone Paul, who piloted the boat initially before owner Dylan Nicholas took command, was among the four people killed. Fisherman Elias Nicholas, a passenger aboard Ocean Angel from Soufriรจre, compared their approaches: "Tyrone was taking it more easy on the boat; Dylan was going more faster," he said.
Dylan Nicholas disputed claims he was speeding. He testified that his speed was "more than moderate" and that he had adjusted it according to wave conditions and sea state.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.