ST. THOMAS: A federal judge has cleared the way for a prisoner to resume an appeal that languished for more than a decade, ruling that his legal representation failed when his attorney was prosecuted, imprisoned and disbarred.
Joel Diaz Hinirio pleaded guilty in 2013 to federal drug and firearms charges while keeping open the option to contest whether certain evidence should have been used against him. On November 18, Chief District Judge Robert Molloy granted him permission to pursue that challenge on appeal. The ruling does not declare Hinirio innocent or order his release; it simply allows the merits of his claim to be heard.
Hinirio's 210-month sentence is due to end in February 2027.
The underlying case began with a June 2011 search at a Lerkenlund residence. A confidential informant brought federal agents to the home, where they spotted what they believed to be drugs and weapons. After securing a warrant, agents found roughly 531 kilograms of cocaine, 6.5 kilograms of marijuana and two firearms. When agents approached Hinirio and a co-defendant outside the house, both men ran into the woods.
Hinirio moved to exclude the evidence and statements he said were obtained unlawfully. In February 2013, the District Court rejected some of his objections and granted others. He then entered his guilty plea while preserving his right to appeal the unfavourable rulings.
The appeal stalled for years. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit returned the case to District Court in December 2014, saying the judge had failed to provide adequate reasoning for allowing the evidence. The written explanation finally came on December 10, 2016, nearly four years after the initial decision.
During this period, Hinirio's lawyer, Federico Ducoudray-Acevedo, faced criminal charges in Puerto Rico unrelated to Hinirio's case. Ducoudray-Acevedo was indicted in 2015, convicted of witness tampering and obstruction of justice in January 2016, and sentenced to 18 months in prison. He entered prison in May 2017 and was disbarred in March 2018, but remained listed as Hinirio's attorney until new counsel took over in November 2023.
Judge Molloy concluded that Hinirio had no functioning advocate while his lawyer was incarcerated. The judge rejected the government's position that the attorney's role had ended and that Hinirio had not clearly pursued further appeal.
"The Government fails to account for the breakdown of Hinirio's defense after the District Court issued its 2016 memorandum opinion," Judge Molloy wrote.
The decision permits Hinirio to move forward with his appeal. The question of whether the evidence should have been excluded will now be decided.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.