VirginIslandsEverything ๐Ÿ”ฅ Viral
COURT

Farm businesses claim retaliation in product approval dispute

Prosperity Farm and RaisingCane allege DLCA withdrew six label approvals days after they sued the agency.

A formal government office building with the US Virgin Islands flag flying, showing official letterhead and administrative documents on a desk, cinematic lighting, no people visible
Illustration (AI-generated)

Prosperity Farm and RaisingCane have taken the Department of Licensing and Consumer Affairs to federal court, claiming that Assistant Commissioner Horace Graham cancelled approval for six products in retaliation for an earlier legal challenge.

The case was filed Friday in the District Court of the Virgin Islands. The businesses say Mr. Graham removed the approvals "without notice and without a hearing" and are seeking an injunction along with compensatory and punitive damages. The complaint names Mr. Graham both personally and in his official role.

According to the lawsuit, DLCA gave the green light to six RaisingCane product labels in July 2025. The following month, the agency approved revised versions of those labels, though the August letter identified the business as Prosperity Farm & Restaurant LLC rather than RaisingCane. The amendments involved changes to information about the products' origin and proof.

RaisingCane relied on both approvals when it started selling the items in September 2025. Within a year, the products had reached bars, restaurants and six grocery stores across the territory.

Tensions rose in June when a DLCA officer told staff at three St. Croix supermarkets they risked fines if they kept stocking the goods. RaisingCane then distributed its approval letters to all 26 of its customer accounts.

The businesses went to federal court in October with a separate lawsuit alleging constitutional violations tied to the supermarket warnings and other agency conduct, including the seizure of a company tractor's license plates. Just 17 days later, Mr. Graham sent a letter withdrawing what he called the "purported approval" from the August communication.

In that letter, Mr. Graham said the August statements "were made inadvertently and prematurely" and were "not issued or distributed through the Department's established review and authorization channels for final agency action." He described the withdrawal as an "administrative correction" rather than a final denial.

The new complaint challenges both how the withdrawal happened and why. The businesses say they received no advance warning, no hearing and no information about appealing. They also point out that Mr. Graham's letter cited reasons from the original July labels to justify the action, even though those reasons did not appear in the August version that was actually approved.

The complaint further notes that Mr. Graham's letter did not mention or withdraw the July approval and did not explain how two substantially similar approvals could have been issued outside normal agency procedures.

The case stems from a wider licensing row. In September, the Department of Health shut down Prosperity Farm's bar, food-service and event operations after finding missing health permits and Fire/EMS approvals. DLCA separately took the position that running a bar, serving alcohol and hosting events went beyond what a commercial farming license allows. The farm's agricultural operations were not closed.

Before pursuing the federal case, the businesses had challenged DLCA's licensing stance in Superior Court.

The new federal complaint alleges violations of First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment rights. It asks the court to stop any further retaliation or enforcement tied to the withdrawal and to hold Mr. Graham personally responsible for damages.

How does this story make you feel?

Sources The Virgin Islands Consortium

๐Ÿ“ฃ Know more about this story? Send us a tip. Photos welcome. Your identity stays private.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.

Create a comment

Comments are checked before they appear.