As the Virgin Islands observes Restorative Justice Week 2026, a University of the West Indies professor has challenged Caribbean governments to abandon their reliance on incarceration as a crime-fighting tool.
Dr Corin A. Bailey, a crime-prevention advocate, says the evidence is stark: simply confining offenders does not transform them into productive citizens upon release. Research across several Caribbean islands has found that 41 per cent of inmates return to prison within two years, a finding that underscores the system's inability to break cycles of reoffending.
Dr Bailey points to a deeper problem. Early involvement with the justice system itself can trap people in a pattern of repeated contact. "As soon as someone comes into contact with the justice system, their chances of being embedded within that system for the rest of their lives increase exponentially," he said.
His remarks follow the recently held Restorative Justice and Pathways Conference in the territory, where he participated in a panel examining how the Virgin Islands might reshape its approach to justice and rehabilitation. The conference was described as a milestone in advancing national conversations on these issues.
Dr Bailey advocates for restorative justice, a model that brings together those affected by harm to address accountability, repair, and reintegration rather than relying on punishment alone. He frames this approach as integral to crime prevention itself, not separate from it.
"I'm in the business of crime prevention, and I see restorative justice as one aspect of that," he said. "What we do after apprehension is just as important as what we do before."
The professor has urged Caribbean governments to acknowledge that current strategies are not working and to adopt alternatives. Advocates say the path forward requires moving beyond conferences and into concrete policy: designing programmes that amplify victims' voices, enforce accountability, and establish pathways for people to reintegrate successfully after involvement with the justice system.
Restorative Justice Week ran internationally from November 15 to 21, highlighting the model's capacity to repair relationships and strengthen communities.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first.